HENRY APPLEBACH (approx 1814-1878)
Henry Applebach was the son of Henry Applebach (Johann Heinrich Afflerbach - emigrant) and Anna Elizabeth Triede (Trude) Applebach. At this point, exact years are conflicting and sketchy but it appears that he was born 1814-1817 and died sometime between 1870-1878.
#1. According to "Six Afflerbach Emigrants Who Came To Pennsylvania and their Descendants 1750-1930" by Jane K. Thompson, pg. 178 lists his siblings as:
Mary 1810-1883 - married to Jacob Rorerbacher
Henry (approx) 1814-1878 married to Catherine (Mary) Stehr/Stahr in 1840 and Ellen Shelly after 1855.
Louise 1815- _____. Married to Mathias Weaver
Susan 1817 - ____. Married to Joseph Clark.
William 1818 - _____. Married to Elmira _________.
Charles 1825 - _______. Married Margaret __________.
According to the same source above, Mary Stehr/Stahr may be the one christened at St. Paul's Lutheran Church in Beaver Township in Clarion, PA on 10 July 1825 and that list says she was the daughter of Michael and Catharina. Henry and Mary married 31 July 1840.
#2. According to Thompson pg. 178-179 and the 1850 census:
Henry is 36 and a laborer
Mary/Catherine is 34
Louise is 9 (dies in 1853)
William is 7
Catherine is 5
Sarah is 3
Abraham born in 1851
#3. After the birth of Abraham, Mary/Catherine drops from sight. Did she die around the time of Abraham's birth? Did she abandon the family? Thompson appears to think it may be connected to Abraham's birth. I grew with my father telling me she had been killed by Indians. However, as an adult, I think this is unlikely as eastern Pennsylvania was very settled in the 1850's and that the Indian story was simply a story - I think she probably died of illness or something connected to Abraham's birth. However, the truth is the children of this union were farmed out to others and Henry disappeared from sight.......or did he?
In the 1860 census for Monroe County, PA - Abraham is listed as living with Samuel and Harriet Mullenberger. In the 1860 census Catherine is living with the George Weiss family as a servant. How were these families connected to Henry and Mary/Catherine Applebach that they ended up with their children? So far, I haven't located the other children in 1860.
According to Thompson, Henry Applebach was living with a woman who is usually called Ellen Shelley, but is also seen in records as having the first name of Sarah, Lanah, and Allina. She was the daughter of John Shelly and was from Hamilton in Monroe County, PA. It appears that they were living together (married??) from 1856 onward. Ellen already had a daughter named Lucinda Shelley (whose father was probably George Hoffner). According to the 1870 census for Carbon County, PA: Henry 55, boot maker
Allina 39
Lucinda 14
Julia (July?) A 11
Ella 10
Ida 8
Margaret 4
Emma 11/12
Further speculation is made by Thompson:
1880 census in Philadelphia are listed 2 nephews in the household of Henry's brother Charles
Frank 10
Charles 9
Could these 2 boys be the sons of Henry and Ellen being raised by Henry's brother after Henry disappears/dies?
#4. Mrs. Ellen Applebaugh married Lewis Lauer on 1 Jan. 1877. In the 1880 census are listed these children: Ellen Applebach age 20, Ide Applebach age 18, Mage age 14, Emma age 11, and Luwise Lauer age 1. If Thompson's research and speculation are correct, three children were born to Emma by her step-father between 1884-1892. Obviously while interesting, right now I am not on the trail of Henry's second family and will leave it rest for now.
#5. Years ago I stumbled upon a Lancaster County directory (below) for 1877-78. I was looking for Abraham and did not pay attention to the name below Abraham until I obtained the Thompson book and realized I needed to look at Henry too. Henry did not have a son named Henry, so it is likely that the Henry in the directory is Abraham's father, but why that date and place?
Abraham and Elizabeth had married in 1872 and by 1877 there should have been children, so why was Abraham boarding in the Eagle Hotel? Did he board closer to his job and go home on weekends? Were Abraham and Elizabeth separated? In my own mind it was one of the first two situations. But, what if Abraham's father Henry - now an old man (kicked out by 2nd wife? Run off by man who replace him as new husband/step-father?) had no where else to go? Or Henry was visiting his youngest son and more or less moved in, and Elizabeth refused to put up with it and both men had to leave? Is it possible that Henry died and is buried somewhere in Lancaster, PA?
How much contact was there between Henry and his first family? Was he not able to care for them properly when Mary/Catherine died, or did he simply dump then with whoever would take them, and then take up with another woman and have a second family?
When it comes to Henry, I have many more questions then answers. I am speculating that he may be buried in Lancaster County somewhere and have died 1877-78. If so, was he buried quietly (cheaply) in a pauper's grave and any records have disappeared? Or could he have been making some sort of circuit visiting each of the children of his first marriage, and died along the way?
According to Thompson, she has not found any death or burial records. She has also not found a marriage record for Henry Applebach and Ellen Shelley - is it possible they just lived together and had a family? If so, could he have deserted them or could Ellen have thrown him out? She legally married Lewis Lauer on 1 Jan. 1877, so where was Henry?
In answer to the question, how sure am I that this Henry is actually Abraham's father?? Besides the records available, I think a big clue is that Abraham was trained as a shoe maker. In Lancaster, he seems to have taken up the occupation of wagon driver between Lancaster and Philadelphia. However, the thread of shoemaker between Abraham and Henry tells me there is a very real chance that they were father and son. It also tells me that they may have been some form of interaction between them, even when Abraham was young. Is it possible that the two of them maintained some sort of relationship even when Henry had gone on to have another family? If so, is it possible that when Henry was old/sick/injured/unwanted that he would turn to the (now) adult child he had a relationship with?
I may never know, or I may stumble upon answers - as yet, Henry Applebach remains a mystery. I do have to wonder how much the possible instability of Abraham's family life growing up lead to the instability of his own children (drunks, multiple marriages, illegitimate grandchildren) and then to his own grandchildren.
#1. According to "Six Afflerbach Emigrants Who Came To Pennsylvania and their Descendants 1750-1930" by Jane K. Thompson, pg. 178 lists his siblings as:
Mary 1810-1883 - married to Jacob Rorerbacher
Henry (approx) 1814-1878 married to Catherine (Mary) Stehr/Stahr in 1840 and Ellen Shelly after 1855.
Louise 1815- _____. Married to Mathias Weaver
Susan 1817 - ____. Married to Joseph Clark.
William 1818 - _____. Married to Elmira _________.
Charles 1825 - _______. Married Margaret __________.
According to the same source above, Mary Stehr/Stahr may be the one christened at St. Paul's Lutheran Church in Beaver Township in Clarion, PA on 10 July 1825 and that list says she was the daughter of Michael and Catharina. Henry and Mary married 31 July 1840.
#2. According to Thompson pg. 178-179 and the 1850 census:
Henry is 36 and a laborer
Mary/Catherine is 34
Louise is 9 (dies in 1853)
William is 7
Catherine is 5
Sarah is 3
Abraham born in 1851
#3. After the birth of Abraham, Mary/Catherine drops from sight. Did she die around the time of Abraham's birth? Did she abandon the family? Thompson appears to think it may be connected to Abraham's birth. I grew with my father telling me she had been killed by Indians. However, as an adult, I think this is unlikely as eastern Pennsylvania was very settled in the 1850's and that the Indian story was simply a story - I think she probably died of illness or something connected to Abraham's birth. However, the truth is the children of this union were farmed out to others and Henry disappeared from sight.......or did he?
In the 1860 census for Monroe County, PA - Abraham is listed as living with Samuel and Harriet Mullenberger. In the 1860 census Catherine is living with the George Weiss family as a servant. How were these families connected to Henry and Mary/Catherine Applebach that they ended up with their children? So far, I haven't located the other children in 1860.
According to Thompson, Henry Applebach was living with a woman who is usually called Ellen Shelley, but is also seen in records as having the first name of Sarah, Lanah, and Allina. She was the daughter of John Shelly and was from Hamilton in Monroe County, PA. It appears that they were living together (married??) from 1856 onward. Ellen already had a daughter named Lucinda Shelley (whose father was probably George Hoffner). According to the 1870 census for Carbon County, PA: Henry 55, boot maker
Allina 39
Lucinda 14
Julia (July?) A 11
Ella 10
Ida 8
Margaret 4
Emma 11/12
Further speculation is made by Thompson:
1880 census in Philadelphia are listed 2 nephews in the household of Henry's brother Charles
Frank 10
Charles 9
Could these 2 boys be the sons of Henry and Ellen being raised by Henry's brother after Henry disappears/dies?
#4. Mrs. Ellen Applebaugh married Lewis Lauer on 1 Jan. 1877. In the 1880 census are listed these children: Ellen Applebach age 20, Ide Applebach age 18, Mage age 14, Emma age 11, and Luwise Lauer age 1. If Thompson's research and speculation are correct, three children were born to Emma by her step-father between 1884-1892. Obviously while interesting, right now I am not on the trail of Henry's second family and will leave it rest for now.
#5. Years ago I stumbled upon a Lancaster County directory (below) for 1877-78. I was looking for Abraham and did not pay attention to the name below Abraham until I obtained the Thompson book and realized I needed to look at Henry too. Henry did not have a son named Henry, so it is likely that the Henry in the directory is Abraham's father, but why that date and place?
 |
| Lancaster Directory 1877-1878 |
How much contact was there between Henry and his first family? Was he not able to care for them properly when Mary/Catherine died, or did he simply dump then with whoever would take them, and then take up with another woman and have a second family?
When it comes to Henry, I have many more questions then answers. I am speculating that he may be buried in Lancaster County somewhere and have died 1877-78. If so, was he buried quietly (cheaply) in a pauper's grave and any records have disappeared? Or could he have been making some sort of circuit visiting each of the children of his first marriage, and died along the way?
According to Thompson, she has not found any death or burial records. She has also not found a marriage record for Henry Applebach and Ellen Shelley - is it possible they just lived together and had a family? If so, could he have deserted them or could Ellen have thrown him out? She legally married Lewis Lauer on 1 Jan. 1877, so where was Henry?
In answer to the question, how sure am I that this Henry is actually Abraham's father?? Besides the records available, I think a big clue is that Abraham was trained as a shoe maker. In Lancaster, he seems to have taken up the occupation of wagon driver between Lancaster and Philadelphia. However, the thread of shoemaker between Abraham and Henry tells me there is a very real chance that they were father and son. It also tells me that they may have been some form of interaction between them, even when Abraham was young. Is it possible that the two of them maintained some sort of relationship even when Henry had gone on to have another family? If so, is it possible that when Henry was old/sick/injured/unwanted that he would turn to the (now) adult child he had a relationship with?
I may never know, or I may stumble upon answers - as yet, Henry Applebach remains a mystery. I do have to wonder how much the possible instability of Abraham's family life growing up lead to the instability of his own children (drunks, multiple marriages, illegitimate grandchildren) and then to his own grandchildren.
Comments
Post a Comment